Elder Abuse Occurs Even in Luxury Care Facilities

Overall, between 2005 and 2006, the California Office of the Attorney General reports that there were 108 criminal filings and 60 convictions for elder abuse, and 25 civil complaints filed and 22 civil judgments for elder abuse. For both criminal civil cases, $4,806,652 was awarded in between 2005 and 2006 in restitution and penalties.

The families of those in nursing homes must continually observe their loved ones to prevent abuse. The California Attorney General’s Crime and Violence Prevention Center provides some indicators for possible abuse:

• Physical indicators include unexplained bruises or welts, poor skin condition or poor skin hygiene, untreated medical conditions, the presence of cuts, pinch marks, skin tears, lacerations or puncture wounds, or the existence of bruises or welts in various stages of healing.


• Behavior indicators include confusion, withdrawal, fear, or anger.


• Social indicators interaction or activity within the family that is restricted or prohibited, or an elder not being given the opportunity to speak for him or herself or see others without the care-giver present.


• Financial indicators include a lack of amenities, such as TV, personal grooming items, or appropriate clothing.
  

More information on the warning signs for elder abuse can be found at http://www.safestate.org/, the California Attorney General’s Crime and Violence Prevention Center.

Elder abuse can occur even in luxury care facilities. When Elmore Kittower, an 80 year-old occupant of Silverado Senior Living in Calabasas, California, passed away, his death was not initially deemed suspicious. Mr. Kittower was paying $75,000 a year to reside at Silverado Senior Living. Shortly after his death, Mr. Kittower’s widow, Rita, was contacted by a woman that claimed to be a Silverado employee. The woman told Mrs. Kittower that her husband had been beaten and suffocated by another employee at the nursing home. This led to a Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department investigation and a finding that the trauma to Mr. Kittower’s body was similar to that of an assault.

Since Mr. Kittower’s death, the investigation of possible elder abuse at Silverado expanded. Authorities examined the possible abuse of three other residents of the nursing home. In an autopsy on Mr. Kittower, it was revealed that he died due to a lung blood clot. The report also stated that “blunt force trauma” was a factor in his death. Mr. Kittower’s body also had multiple bruises and showed evidence of a partially healed rib fracture. Another resident alleged to have been harmed is the mother of Keith Stubbs. Stubbs learned from authorities that his mother’s chest was jumped on. Stubbs said he did not suspect that his mother had been abused. In retrospect, Stubbs noted that he started seeing bruises on his mother’s arms and neck, and that he recently noticed that his mother recoiled when she was touched by visiting loved ones, something she had not done previously. The other possible victims are Silverado residents, Richard McDonough and Robert Turner. Authorities have said that Turner was punched in the stomach.

A former Silverado caregiver, Cesar Ulloa, has been implicated in the investigation. Ulloa has been charged with four counts of elder abuse and one count of torture. Ulloa was arraigned this week in Los Angeles Superior Court. He entered a not guilty plea.

Silverado spokesman Mark Mostow said that the company screens its potential employees and conducts background checks. He also said that all employees undergo an elder-abuse reporting program conducted by the California Department of Justice. Mostow indicated that Ulloa, who Silverado fired last year, appeared to have a friendly and outgoing demeanor and that families of the residents of Silverado received him well.

The Silverado case illustrates that even expensive facilities are not immune from elderly abuse. If you have a loved one in a nursing home or care facility, visit frequently and be alert for signs of possible abuse.

Thanks for reading my blog. If you have a comment or question, please feel free to reply to this posting, or send me an e-mail. If you suspect that a loved one has been the victim of elder abuse, contact me to schedule a confidential consultation and for immediate assistance.

New Elder Abuse Laws Signed by Governor Schwarzenegger

California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed into law this week several bills aimed at curbing elder abuse and providing greater protection for the elderly in the State of California. Here is a brief summary of the new laws:

AB 2100 requires ombudspersons at long-term care facilities to report cases of alleged or suspected physical abuse, including sexual abuse, and financial abuse to the local district attorney’s office. The purpose of this bill is to encourage the reporting of suspected cases of abuse.

SB 1140 extends the statute of limitations for a claim for damages due to financial elder abuse to four years from the plaintiff discovers, or should have discovered, the abuse. Presently, the statute of limitations on such a claim is three years. In addition, the definition of financial abuse of an elder is expanded to include the action of taking, appropriating, obtaining or retaining, real or personal property by undue influence.

SB 1136 makes it a misdemeanor to charge an “unconscionable fee” to qualify a person for a public social service benefit, including Medi-Cal.

AB 225 extends the protection of a restraining order to include named family members, household members and conservators of the elder abuse victim.

AB 2149 regulates the use of “expertise” designations and requires advisors to take training courses before holding themselves out as having specialized knowledge regarding the financial needs of seniors. The bill is designed to prevent the elderly from falling prey to unscrupulous financial advisors who claim to be experts on financial planning for the elderly.

Also signed into law were two bills targeting nursing home and residential care facilities. AB 2370 requires residential care facilities to post information regarding recent rate increases on an annual basis, and also requires the disclosure of rate increase information to new residents, and, upon request, to prospective residents. AB 749 requires residential care facilities to have a comprehensive emergency plan by March 1, 2009 that provides that the facility will be self-reliant if necessary for at least 72 hours. The plan must be available to residents and emergency personnel.

The new laws are designed to protect the elderly in the event of a disaster and protect them from financial elder abuse.

Thanks for reading my blog. If you suspect that a loved one has been the victim of elder abuse, contact me to schedule a confidential consultation and for immediate assistance.

California Department of Public Health Fines Nursing Homes

The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) issued citations and fines to several nursing homes in April 2008. Nursing homes licensed by California are subject to citations and fines for poor or negligent care. Citations and the fines issued by the CDPH are categorized by class, with Class AA being the most severe. The classes break down in the following manner:

• Class AA: $25,000 to $100,000 fine
• Class A: $2,000 to $20,000 fine
• Class B: $100 to $1,000 fine

The significance and severity of the violation determines the citation class and the amount of the imposed fine. Although several facilities were issued citations, the following three are examples of the most egregious.

Palm Terrace Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center
The Palm Terrace Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center in Laguna Hills was fined $75,000 for actions relating to the death of a resident. Despite observing the resident to be tired and lethargic, the staff allowed her to eat alone in her room. The resident choked on a piece of meat; she was hospitalized and died three days later. At the hospital, it was discovered that the patient had overdosed on morphine despite the lack of a prescription from her physician. The autopsy revealed that there were very high levels of morphine in her blood, and the coroner concluded that she had been dosed over a period of time prior to the choking. The coroner also concluded that there was a high probability that the morphine played a role in her choking. The police homicide office investigated the incident and could not determine who had administered the morphine to the patient. The CDPH determined that Palm Terrace failed to identify the patient’s care needs which resulted in the resident’s death and issued a Class AA citation.

The Springs at the Carlotta in Palm Desert
The Springs at the Carlotta in Palm Desert was fined $100,000 by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). The Springs was also issued an “AA” citation. The CDPH concluded, after an investigation, that inadequate care led to the death of an 87-year-old resident in June of 2006. It concluded that the Springs failed to “identify the care needs” of the patient “based on an initial and continuing assessment.” This failure by the nursing home “presented an imminent danger” to the patient “and was the direct and proximate cause of death.” The resident had been admitted with a diagnosis of potential constipation (among other things). The facility was supposed to monitor and record the resident's bowel movements. The facility failed to properly monitor the bowel movements. After several days, the resident was vomiting and her abdomen was distended. She was transferred to a hospital where she died that same day of “Acute Peritonitis due to perforated colon due to severe constipation.”

Marysville Care Center
The Marysville Care Center in Yuba City was issued a Class AA citation and a $100,000 fine relating to the death of an 84 year old resident. She had been diagnosed with osteoarthritis, psychosis, and Alzheimer's disease and was totally dependent on the facility for her daily living needs. The CDPH reported that the facility failed to keep the resident “free from accident hazards” by not to putting down the side rails on the resident's bed. These side rails were to be used only when the resident was being turned. The report also indicated that the facility did not use a bed alarm that would notify staff if the resident attempted to get out of bed. The resident was found with her chin resting on the lower part of the bed rail with her feet on the floor. Her head was stuck between the bed rail and the bed. She was unable to free herself and choked to death.

Neglect and Elder Abuse
These three incidents of neglect are all examples of elder abuse. When visiting a loved one at a nursing home, be on the lookout for signs of neglect such as poor hygiene, dirty fingernails, signs of feces or smells of urine, unexplained weight loss, and bedsores. Facilities with staffing problems are especially prone to neglect. Staffing problems lead to high staff turnover and inadequately trained or inexperienced staff.

Thanks for reading. If you have a question or comment, feel free to reply to this posting, or send me an e-mail. If you suspect a nursing home's negligence or neglect has resulted in the injury or death of a loved one, contact me for help and immediate assistance.

Assisted Living Facilities vs. Skilled Nursing Homes

The term “assisted living” became popular in the 1980’s and is used within the retirement industry to refer to programs available in many retirement residences, senior apartment facilities and residential care facilities in California. Many retirement residences recognized a growing need for personal care programs. These types of programs allow residents to remain independent in their apartment. The cost of living in an assisted living facility is about $3200 a month on average, as compared to approximately $5,000 a month for a semi-private room in a nursing home.

Residents in assisted living facilities require less care than residents of nursing homes. Typically, a residence in an assisted living facility will require some assistance with one or more of the following: help with bathing or dressing, assistance with taking medication, assistance with toileting or incontinence, and special dietary requirements. Assisted living facilities are not permitted to provide skilled nursing services, such as diabetic insulin injections or colostomy care, although they may contract with an outside provider for these services.

Assisted living facilities are licensed by the Community Care Division of the California Department of Social Services http://ccld.ca.gov/. Nursing homes are licensed by the California Department of Health Services http://www.dhcs.ca.gov/Pages/default.aspx and are given a higher level of scrutiny by the licensing authority since they are considered a health care facility.

As the population ages, the popularity of assisted living facilities has grown. Claims against assisted living facilities are also increasing. Some assisted living facilities have been accused of holding on to residents in declining health that should have been referred to nursing home facilities or a hospital. Unfortunately, one challenge that plaintiffs face is collecting on a judgment; assisted living facilities are often uninsured.

Thanks for reading. Feel free to leave a comment or reply to this posting, but keep in mind that your response will not be confidential. If you have a question or need assistance regarding a possible claim involving an assisted living facility or nursing home, contact me for help and immediate assistance.

What is Elder Abuse?

California law says that an "elder" is a person who is 65 or older. Elder abuse can be in the form of physical abuse, neglect, financial abuse, abandonment, isolation, abduction, or other treatment with resulting physical harm or pain or mental suffering. To deprive an elder person of goods and services that result in physical harm or pain or mental suffering is also elder abuse.

Unfortunately, the elderly are often vulnerable to mistreatment. The National Center on Elder Abuse estimates that between 1 million and 2 million elderly Americans have been victims of elder abuse. We can imagine that the numbers are probably much higher due to incidents that go unreported.

The purpose of my blog is to disseminate information about elder abuse in the United States. I hope that by doing so, we can better identify situations where our beloved elderly need our assistance in preventing an abusive situation that can hamper their lives.

I will post again soon. Feel free to contact me if you have specific questions, or respond to this blog for general comments.

Thanks for reading.